Work in progress: draft findings
The Church of Scientology owns 64 properties in and around Clearwater, Florida, and uses a 65th that it does not own. This report counts the registered voters who give one of those addresses as their home, then shows what the records reveal about residential density, centralized mailing, voter turnout and registration timing. It also states plainly what the numbers do not prove.
How many people are registered to vote at addresses the Church of Scientology owns or uses in Clearwater, Florida?
Public records, including the Pinellas County voter roll (606,000 active registrations), the county’s inactive voter-registration records and the county Property Appraiser’s property files.
Someone on the county voter-registration records who gives that address as the place they live. The headline total covers active registrations and inactive ones that remain registered. It counts registrations, not everyone in the building: children, non-citizens and anyone who never registered do not appear in it.
An analytical classification used throughout this report. It rests on the registration addresses, property associations and other records analyzed here. It is not independent confirmation that every individual is a Sea Org member.
They do not show that anyone is registered improperly. Crowded staff housing, group registration drives, a shared mailing address and high turnout in an organized community can each be lawful, and each is noted where it comes up.
Every voter is counted once, at the address recorded as their residence. Active and inactive registrations are shown separately.
Separately, 10 more active registrations have their mail sent to one of these addresses but list a different residence. Counting them as well, 1,824 registered voters touch this network in some way, and 1,823 are registered inside Clearwater. Section 12 sets the totals side by side.
The headcount is only the starting point. These are the largest, oldest, rarest and otherwise most notable patterns in the records, each listed once. Findings that cut against the anomaly reading are stated where they arise.
Crowded staff housing, an organized community that turns out, a shared mailing address and assisted group registration can each be lawful, and each is noted where it appears.
How to read the table. One row per address, largest first. Each person appears once, on the row where they live. “Per unit” is the number of active registered voters divided by the number of apartments or rooms in the building. An ordinary Pinellas County apartment block runs at about 1.0, so a figure near 3 or 4 means several registered adults in every apartment.
| Address | Apartments or rooms | Active registered voters | Per unit |
|---|---|---|---|
| Church ownedHacienda Gardens551 N Saturn Ave | 198 | 887 | 4.5 |
| Church ownedSherwood Garden Apartments1791 Sherwood St, registered as “1301 Amble Ln” | 112 | 396 | 3.5 |
| Sea Org housing21030 US Highway 19 NThe former Clearwater Inn. Owned by Pinellas Corridor LLC, not the Church. On the records analyzed, used exclusively as housing for probable Sea Org voters. | 178 | 180 | 1.0 |
| Church owned1850 N Ft Harrison AveFormer motel | 50 | 164 | 3.3 |
| Church owned1024 Cleveland StFormer motel | 54 | 50 | 0.9 |
| Church owned118 N Ft Harrison AveChurch building, capacity unknown | n/a | 39 | n/a |
| Church ownedOak Cove210 S Osceola Ave, former hotel | 232 | 14 | 0.06 |
| Church owned210 S Ft Harrison AveFormer hotel | n/a | 9 | n/a |
| Church owned1840 N Ft Harrison Ave | 22 | 4 | 0.18 |
| Church owned20788 US Highway 19 N | n/a | 4 | n/a |
| Church owned221 N Osceola AveFormer hotel | 85 | 3 | 0.04 |
| Church owned711 Cleveland StFormer motel | 47 | 2 | 0.04 |
| Total active registrations, all reported residential addressesAll twelve rows above | 1,752 | ||
| Of that total, on property the Church ownsThe eleven Church owned rows only | 1,572 |
A further ten people have their mail sent to one of these addresses but live somewhere else. Section 12 shows how they are counted.
Hacienda Gardens and Sherwood Garden Apartments together account for 1,283 of the 1,572. The other nine Church-owned addresses hold 289 between them. The two large complexes are also the only Church properties far above normal density.
The apartments are ordinary in size: about 1,040 sq ft each at Hacienda Gardens and about 940 sq ft at Sherwood. Every other large apartment complex in Pinellas County has roughly one registered voter per apartment.
These ratios count registered voters only. They leave out children under 18, non-US citizens and other residents who are not registered to vote. It has been reported that 50 to 70 percent of Sea Org members are non-US citizens, which means a large share of actual residents would not appear in voter-registration counts. The true occupancy density is therefore substantially higher than the voter-based ratios alone suggest.
Note the direction: Bay View Isles has three times as many apartments and half as many registered voters. No address in Pinellas County has more registered voters than Hacienda Gardens, and it is the only ordinary apartment block at the top of that list. The addresses level with it are sprawling mobile-home communities of 800-plus separate lots.
Shared or dormitory-style staff housing can hold more adults per apartment than ordinary rentals, and that can be lawful. Whether these particular buildings are permitted to house this many adults is a city zoning question the voter records cannot answer.
396 voters give 1301 Amble Ln as their home. That address cannot be found in the county property records, because no such property exists. Amble Lane is a street of 36 duplexes, and its odd-numbered side stops at 1211.
They live at Sherwood Garden Apartments, 1791 Sherwood St: 112 apartments in eight buildings, owned by the Church of Scientology Religious Trust since 2007. The complex backs onto Amble Lane and uses it as its entrance. Three strands of the record agree:
180 people are registered at this address, and 138 of them send their mail to a Church building downtown. That is 77% of the building, the highest share of any building in Pinellas County and higher than Hacienda Gardens itself. These 180 active registrations are part of the headline count because they belong to the same residential network, even though the property is not Church-owned.
Three ownership facts remain important. No Church entity appears on the title at any point back to 2002. The company owns no other parcel in Pinellas County, and its Tampa address is unconnected to any Church mailing address. It also claims no religious or institutional exemption. By contrast, Sherwood Garden Apartments is assessed at almost the same value, $9.8m, but is taxed on only $920,220 of it, because the Church does claim that exemption there.
The density pattern here differs from Hacienda Gardens and Sherwood. 180 registered voters in 178 rooms is about 1.0 registered voter per room. The voter file shows no crowding at this property. What stands out is that a former hotel now functions as dedicated residential housing for probable Sea Org voters.
These 180 active registrations are inside the headline 1,814 and the 1,752 active registrations. They are outside the 1,572, which counts active registrations only at addresses the Church owns outright.
These voters are not a separate group of people. 462 of the 465 are already counted in the address table in section 2, at the addresses where they live.
207 S Garden Ave receives more voter mail than any other street address in Pinellas County. Property records name the Church of Scientology Flag Service Org as the owner of both 207 S Garden Ave and 503 Cleveland St.
One organization providing housing at several properties and collecting residents’ mail centrally can be lawful. Florida does not require your mailing address to match your home.
A large count at one address could reflect registrations that are no longer active in practice. Turnout in the August 2026 primary shows that this is not the case at the largest addresses.
| Turnout among eligible voters | Nov 2024 general | Aug 2026 primary | Change |
|---|---|---|---|
| All Clearwater | 86.7% | 34.1% | −52.6 |
| Church ownedHacienda Gardens | 89.6% | 94.5% | +4.9 |
| Sea Org housing21030 US Highway 19 N | 89.6% | 92.7% | +3.1 |
| Church ownedSherwood Garden Apts | 86.7% | 90.6% | +3.9 |
Citywide turnout fell 53 points between those two elections. At Hacienda Gardens it went up. In the 2024 general these addresses were unremarkable. In the 2026 primary they were the top three buildings in Clearwater, 24 points clear of fourth place.
Pinellas assigns voter ID numbers in the order registrations are processed, so records filed together sit together. On 19 May 2023, thirty registrations from five different buildings landed in three tight stretches of the county roll, several of them on numbers one apart. Counting every Pinellas record inside those stretches, thirty of thirty-two are from these addresses.
19 May 2023: thirty registrations from five buildings
Actual voter ID numbers, lowest to highest, in the order Pinellas issued them
Stretch one18 Pinellas records in this range, 17 of them from these buildings
Stretch two6 Pinellas records in this range, 5 of them from these buildings
Stretch three8 Pinellas records in this range, all 8 from these buildings
Every number above is a real voter ID from the public roll, in ascending order. They are tightly clustered, and six pairs and triples are consecutive, one number apart, as marked. The rest sit a few numbers from each other. What matters is what falls between them: across the three stretches these thirty occupy, the Pinellas roll holds thirty-two records in total, and thirty are from these five buildings.
Residents of separate buildings, miles apart, entered the county system in one nearly unbroken block. Individually mailed forms would not normally produce that pattern. The records are consistent with one party collecting registration forms across multiple properties and filing them together.
19 May 2023 is the largest of these days, not the only one. Fifteen days going back to 2000 show the same signature, 189 registrations in all, and no other property portfolio in Pinellas County produces this pattern at all.
Every multi-building batch day, 2000 to 2026
Registrations from two or more of these buildings landing together in the county sequence
Fifteen days, 189 registrations, spanning two to six buildings each. Nine of the fifteen fall in 2022 and later. Some other days carry more registrations, 39 on 30 June 2023 and 19 on 10 March 2023, but those are spread through the day’s sequence rather than arriving in one block, so they do not meet this stricter test.
Batch registration can be lawful and ordinary. Registration drives and assisted group registration do produce this pattern, and Florida licenses organizations to run them. This shows how the records were created, not that anything about them is wrong.
The 1,814 probable Sea Org voters did not all join the Clearwater, Florida voter rolls at the same time. Placing each one in the year they first registered gives a running total. It is plotted here against a control: Clearwater’s average growth rate over the same years, normalized to the same 2015 level. Both lines share one scale, so the distance between them is the excess.
New Clearwater, Florida voter registrations, 2015 to 2026
Growth in Scientology’s probable Sea Org voter registrations in Clearwater, against a control group: Clearwater’s average yearly increase, normalized for comparison
Scroll sideways to see the full chart.
The shaded band marks 2022 and 2023.
From 2015 to 2021 the two lines are the same line. The probable Sea Org voters went from 537 at the end of 2015 to 781 at the end of 2021, a rise of 45%. The Clearwater average rose 47% over those same six years, which puts the control at 792, eleven ahead. Whatever was driving registration in Clearwater over that period was driving it here at the same rate.
Then the two separate, and never converge again. 288 probable Sea Org voters joined the rolls in 2022 and 407 in 2023. That is 695 in all, 38% of the entire count, in two of the eleven years shown. Across those two years the test group grew 89% against the control’s 11%, 8.2 times the rate. By 2026 the probable Sea Org voters stand at 1,814 against 981, an increase of 132% since 2021 against 24% for the Clearwater average. After 2023 the pace falls back to something ordinary, at 118, 103 and 117 in 2024, 2025 and 2026, but the gap opened in those two years is never given back. They are the same two years in which the multi-building batch filings in section 7 are concentrated.
The years of parity are what make the break readable. A survivorship effect lifts every recent cohort of any population drawn from a present-day snapshot, so a population that had always outgrown its city would leave this chart ambiguous. These voters did not always outgrow it. They tracked the Clearwater average for six years, moved once, and then resumed its pace at a permanently higher level.
One thing the chart cannot do is date arrivals. A registration date belongs to the person, not the address: someone who moved into one of these buildings in 2023 carrying a 2001 Florida registration is counted in the 2001 column, not in 2023. That bias runs in a single direction. It lifts the early years and holds down 2022 and 2023, so it flattens the break rather than creating it. Every voter here who transferred in from another Florida address carrying an older date makes the real growth at these buildings higher than what is drawn. The rates above are a floor, not a ceiling.
The pattern is specific. Turnout runs far above the city average in municipal elections and primaries, and at or below it in general elections. Clearwater races are decided in the first kind.
| Election | Type | Probable Sea Org voters | Rest of Clearwater | Ratio |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 17 Mar 2020 | City + primary | 73.4% | 42.8% | 1.72× |
| 18 Aug 2020 | Primary | 57.5% | 37.5% | 1.53× |
| 3 Nov 2020 | General | 87.2% | 92.1% | 0.95× |
| 15 Mar 2022 | City | 96.5% | 33.6% | 2.87× |
| 23 Aug 2022 | Primary | 39.7% | 38.9% | 1.02× |
| 8 Nov 2022 | General | 92.2% | 73.2% | 1.26× |
| 19 Mar 2024 | City + primary | 93.5% | 36.2% | 2.58× |
| 20 Aug 2024 | Primary | 42.9% | 28.6% | 1.50× |
| 5 Nov 2024 | General | 85.3% | 86.7% | 0.98× |
| 18 Aug 2026 | City + primary | 86.8% | 32.7% | 2.65× |
City means a Clearwater local election. A plus sign means more than one type was on the ballot that day.
Two of the general elections cut the other way. In November 2024 and November 2020 the probable Sea Org voters turned out slightly below the rest of Clearwater, at 0.98× and 0.95×. A population registered in order to vote would be expected to show up everywhere. This one shows up where the margins are small and sits out where they are not.
573 people, 53.4% of everyone here whose first ballot can be observed, cast their first-ever vote at the March 2024 Clearwater municipal election. Among ordinary Clearwater voters that election accounts for 4.8% of first ballots.
The reverse is just as sharp. Only 2.6% of the probable Sea Org voters first voted at the November 2024 general, against 40.5% of everyone else. A general election is how the public normally enters the electorate. That is not the case here. And 90.4% voted at the very first election they were eligible for, against 47.3%.
Registrations at these addresses do not arrive evenly. They arrive in bursts, and some of those bursts sit close to a Clearwater election. This section puts the two side by side. A registration date records when a person first joined the Florida voter rolls, not when they moved in, so what follows is a record of when people entered the electorate.
Registrations by month, 2019 to 2026
Every registration in this report, placed in the month the voter first joined the Florida rolls. Dashed lines mark the elections that decided something in Clearwater.
Scroll sideways to see the full chart.
The window starts in 2019. Two earlier bursts sit outside it: 45 registrations in May and June 2000, and 94 in August and September 2013. Both are covered in the timeline below.
The autumn 2022 stack is drawn from the long-occupied buildings. The summer 2023 stack is not. From September 2022 to April 2023, 371 registrations arrived, and all but a handful came from the three buildings that had been full of people for years. No new address contributed anything.
From May to July 2023 the pattern inverts. Of 190 registrations, 93 came from 1850 N Ft Harrison Ave, an address that had produced one or two registrations a year before that. The building itself is not new. It is a former motel the Church has owned for years, and so are the other two. What changed is the registrations, not the buildings. Whether that reflects people newly housed there can be settled only by occupancy records, which this report does not have. The 2022 wave has no such explanation available to it, because those buildings were already full.
Construction halts in 2003 and the city fines the Church daily, suspecting deliberate delay.
The largest day is 6 June 2000, with 19. No Clearwater election sits near this burst, and nothing in the record marks that year as consequential for these addresses.
All of it at the three long-occupied buildings. 14 August 2013 alone carries 24, of which 22 landed bunched together in the county file. This is the same signature the report describes in section 7, a decade before the elections discussed here.
The August burst lands two to three months before the opening, which is when staff for a newly opening building would be arriving. This burst has an explanation that is not electoral, and it is the clearest example in the record of one.
Companies tied to Church members buy more than 200 properties in and around downtown, most of them left vacant. From this point the Church’s downtown footprint is a standing issue in Clearwater politics.
15 of them on 14 December 2019, inside the registration window for the March election.
Mayor and two council seats. Mark Bunker, one of the Church’s most prominent local critics, narrowly wins Seat 2. Turnout at these addresses was 73.4% against a citywide 42.8%, 1.72×.
Nine days before the registration deadline for the March election.
Seat 5 goes to Lina Teixeira over Aaron Smith-Levin, another prominent critic, a former member turned activist and YouTube commentator, who campaigned on the Church’s role in the city. Citywide turnout was about 25%. Turnout at these addresses was 96.5% against 33.6%, 2.87×.
The largest day is 20 September 2022 with 32, three weeks before the deadline. 83 of these registered in time for the November ballot, and 75 of the 83 voted. A further 17 registered on 11 October, one day past the deadline, and so could not.
Voters were asked whether the city could sell two downtown waterfront parcels for a $400m hotel and apartment project. The developers have no Church connection. It passed. This is the only general election in this report where turnout at these addresses runs above the city, 92.2% against 73.2%. In the other three generals they sit at or just below it.
Two of them are batch-filing days, 27 January and 8 March 2023.
Frank Hibbard steps down over a roughly $90m city hall project and the council appoints a replacement for the remaining 11 months. The seat was due to be filled in March 2024 in any case. What changed is that it became an open race with no elected incumbent.
93 of them at 1850 N Ft Harrison Ave, which had produced almost none before. The largest single day in the whole file, 30 June 2023 with 39, falls here. The batch-filing days in this run sit 101 to 150 days from the nearest registration deadline, and that deadline belonged to an election Clearwater was not voting in.
Five days before the registration deadline for the March election.
Bruce Rector wins the mayoralty. Seat 2 goes to Ryan Cotton over the incumbent Mark Bunker by 669 votes. Voters also passed a charter amendment creating runoffs and moving city elections from March to August from 2026. Turnout at these addresses was 93.5% against 36.2%, 2.58×. 1,382 ballots were cast from these addresses, 573 of them first-ever ballots. Of the people who registered between June 2022 and this election, 657 of 711 voted in it.
A 470-foot stretch of public street, at no cost, for a 3,500-seat hall and plaza. Police put about 2,000 people outside city hall. Two of the three votes in favour were elected on 19 March 2024. 207 S Garden Ave, the Church building that receives mail for 465 of these voters and is the largest shared mailing address in Pinellas County, stands on that street.
Filed across six different buildings and bunched together in the county file, the widest spread of properties in any single batch day in the record. 149 of these voters registered in the year ending at this deadline.
Seats 4 and 5. Seat 4 is decided. Seat 5 goes to a runoff, with Mark Bunker in it. Turnout at these addresses was 86.8% against a citywide 32.7%, 2.65×, from 1,520 ballots.
A residents’ group reports passing the signature threshold needed to put the street transfer to a citywide vote.
A second citywide vote touching the Church’s downtown plans can follow if the petition signatures are certified. These 1,814 registrations go into both.
What this section does not show. It shows timing, and nothing more. A registration date records entry onto the Florida rolls, so none of these bursts can be read as arrivals at a building. The records do not show who submitted any registration, whether anyone was asked to register, or how any person voted. Assisted group registration is lawful, and a community that turns out to vote is exercising an ordinary right.
The table shows the age at which the probable Sea Org voters first registered in Florida, grouped by age band. For each band it gives their number and share, the corresponding share for the rest of Clearwater, and the ratio between the two.
| First registered at | Probable Sea Org voters | Share | Rest of Clearwater | Ratio |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Under 30 | 604 | 33.1% | 40.3% | 0.82× |
| 30 to 39 | 379 | 20.8% | 18.9% | 1.10× |
| 40 to 49 | 333 | 18.3% | 14.9% | 1.23× |
| 50 to 59 | 237 | 13.0% | 13.0% | 1.00× |
| 60 to 69 | 202 | 11.1% | 9.1% | 1.21× |
| 70 to 79 | 59 | 3.2% | 3.2% | 1.01× |
| 80 and over | 10 | 0.6% | 0.6% | 0.90× |
A late first registration in Florida has three possible causes that this field cannot tell apart: moving to Florida from another state (much the commonest in Clearwater), naturalization, and a citizen who simply never registered before. Only the statewide voter extract can separate the first from the other two.
These totals measure different things and should not be treated as competing estimates.
Whether you can vote in a Clearwater city election depends on living inside the city limits, never on where your mail is sent. Only one person in the broader mailing-address count lives outside those limits. So all 1,814 registered residents are within Clearwater and able to cast a ballot in a Clearwater city election. Of those, 1,752 are currently active and 62 are currently inactive.
Being registered at an address is not the same as living there today. A registration stays on the rolls until the person registers somewhere else.
A high number is not by itself evidence that anything is wrong. Shared or dormitory-style staff housing can hold more adults per apartment than ordinary rentals, and that can be lawful.
Nothing here identifies any individual as improperly registered. Showing that would require independent evidence that someone actually lives somewhere else, or is ineligible to vote for another reason, such as not being a US citizen. The records reviewed here do not yet provide that.